2016 年，來自印度申請人讀完機械工程師文憑課程。雖然實踐課程成績理想，但大部分理論課程不合格。同時，其兩次學簽申請就讀加拿大萊爾學院的機械技術員文憑課程均被拒。 2022 年，申請人獲阿爾伯塔省紅河學院卡車運輸技術文憑課程錄取，併申請學簽。加拿大移民局第三次拒絕其學簽申請。他就此申請司法審查。 加拿大聯邦法院批准了其司法審查。法官認爲移民官未能解釋清楚申請人之前學業低分如何將導致其無法完成卡車運輸技術文憑課程。 In 2016, the applicant, an Indian citizen, completed a diploma program in Mechanical Engineer. Although he passed the practical courses of the program, he failed most of the theory courses. He applied twice for study permits to attend the Mechanical Technician Diploma at St Clair College. IRCC refused both applications. In 2022, he received an acceptance letter to study a Diploma Program in Truck Transportation Technology at Red River College in Alberta and applied for a study permit. IRCC refused the application. He sought judicial review of the IRCC officer’s decision. The Federal Court of Canada granted his judicial review. The Officer failed to explain how the Applicant’s educational goals were inconsistent and how his previous low grades in certain Engineering topics would cause him issues in his Truck Transportation Technology Diploma program.